Jump to content

Sign in to follow this  
roger sercombe

Is Goldenear Passive speaker worth the extra over Monitor Audio?

Recommended Posts

Hi, I would love to know which is better: 

Monitor Audio PB2 $1000NZ or the PB3 which is slightly wider than the tv, but only $200 more?...can the pb3 justify the worse cosmetics for a better center speaker sound?


$1500 gets me the Goldenear superCinema 3D Array X (not the large XL).

I assume this is worth the extra spend...but I cannot get to listen to them and hope someone else has an opinion. I love watching tv and movies more than listening to music, but still like good quality...I don't like bright harsh sounding speakers over mu

History: My old faithful 5.1 system is upset now that my wife has purchased a corner suite that means my front left floorstanding (old Acoustic Research) speaker has to go! To keep things simple a passive soundbar will replace my front and center speakers and sit above my 55" panasonic VT55 on a ledge. (as the stand doesn't leave enough room to place the bar below the tv on my unit.) I have a Yamaha receiver RX-V1900, yamaha yst-sw500 sub and some cheap kenwood book shelf rears. (my center speaker will be sold)

I had considered the samsung HW-MS650 soundbar and the impressive $2200 HW-N950 full surround system but they seems like starting again when I have good bones already? ....however I do not believe that this is the better audio/movie quality choice...as surely having all in one means less quality?

Any experiences or opinions would be much appreciated.

Cheers image.gif.d1eb213a0d155e718b8e72ccb3582906.gif


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Popular Contributors

  • Posts

    • We first wrote about the HD Vinyl concept back in October 2018. The good news is, the first test grooves have been cut, and Rebeat Innovation says they'll be able to deliver HD Vinyl to your turntable by the second-half of 2019. View the full article
    • Hello reubymac and welcome!   Look forward to your contributions.  
    • Those fortunate enough to be already sporting one of Sony's latest IMAX Enhanced projectors, and a capable Arcam, Denon or Marantz AV Receiver will be pleased to know DTS has announced the first IMAX Enhanced 4K Blu-rays. View the full article
    • Hey, good to find a forum like this in New Zealand. I'm quite new to this whole hi-fi (well, medium-fi on my budget) / home theatre thing. I'm piece-mealing together a system from cheap but relatively good components sourced largely from Trade Me.  There's always lots of a questions along the way, and I'm sure there's plenty of wisdom around here to help out. I'm hoping there might be some selling posts from time to time too? I'm a member of a couple of overseas forums and the amount of cool stuff I just can't access is quite frustrating! Anyhow, thanks for having me, and I look forward to getting involved. 
    • Watch the high voltages with tube gear! Great to see the interest in tube tech being picked up by someone born in the 21st century. Plenty of bargains out there for old stuff to cannibalize - good luck!